So here we are: Washington is once again cranking up the noncitizen-voting panic like somebody found an old CB radio behind the bar and decided every burst of static was a five-alarm emergency. The Associated Press reported that the Trump administration is claiming, without publicly providing evidence, that as many as 250,000 noncitizens may be on voter rolls in California, Nevada, New Jersey, and Pennsylvania.
The administration’s latest fuel is a Census Bureau “beginning analysis” that said 24,000 noncitizens voted illegally in 2020. But AP’s fact-checking review found that the report did not establish that conclusion: its underlying match process could generate false positives, and it omitted the sort of error-rate information needed to evaluate the result. In other words, it’s less a case file than an empty manila folder with a government logo on it. Real confidence-builder, fellas.
Pennsylvania’s Republican secretary of the commonwealth, Al Schmidt, said DHS officials acknowledged they did not have high confidence that the 14,576 people cited in its initial letter were noncitizens improperly registered to vote, according to AP’s reporting. New Jersey did disclose a serious motor-vehicle registration error involving about 6,600 noncitizens in 2023 and 2024, but state officials said fewer than 400 of those people voted and that the registrations resulted from a vendor-related failure—not proof that a nationwide fraud buffet has opened next to the onion rings. AP reported the state’s account here.
Noncitizen voting is illegal, can carry severe penalties, and is widely documented as rare. Still, the administration’s claims arrive alongside renewed pressure for federal legislation requiring documentary proof of citizenship to register—a requirement that could create hurdles for eligible citizens who do not have easy access to the specified paperwork. AP reported that a University of Maryland estimate put the number of eligible voters without easy access to citizenship documents at 21.3 million.
The immediate issue is not whether states should maintain accurate rolls—obviously they should; that is called doing the job. It is whether federal power gets used to turn unverified numbers into suspicion, suspicion into barriers, and barriers into an excuse to dispute an election afterward. That’s not election integrity. That’s leaving empty Michelob bottles around the ballot box and calling it an audit.
Sources
- Associated Press — Noncitizen voting claims animate Trump’s attacks on midterms and set up potential result challenges
- Associated Press — Census report does not prove Trump’s claim about 2020 noncitizen voting
- Associated Press — 6,600 noncitizens registered to vote in New Jersey, governor says
From the Dick Bulger channel
No new channel videos landed in this 12-hour window.
Featured image: Census Bureau headquarters, Suitland, Maryland, 2007.jpg by United States Census Bureau / Oficina del Censo de los Estados Unidos, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.
